The best late round draft picks in Minnesota Vikings history

The Vikings have selected some great players in later rounds of the NFL Draft during their 56 years in the league. You don’t have to be a first round draft pick to have a great career in the NFL, and these Viking players, some of whom played their entire careers with Minnesota, prove that talent can be found anywhere.

10) Terry Allen, RB, round 9, 1991: Allen rushed for over one thousand yards twice in his three years with the Vikings, and totaled 8,614 yards on the ground in a ten year career with five teams.

9) Brad Johnson, QB, round 9, 1992: Johnson played seven seasons with the Vikes; he made the Pro Bowl with the Redskins and the Buccaneers, also winning the Super Bowl with Tampa in 2002. Dumb Dennis Green and ya-hoo owner Red McCombs made the mistake of trading Johnson for draft picks after the 1998 season and instead held on to washed-up choke artist QB Randall Cunningham (who played in a mere six games the following season before being unceremoniously dumped onto the scrap heap).

8) Jeff Wright, S, round 15, 1971: Wright was a solid safety on the Vikings great defenses and Super Bowl teams from 1973-1977.

7) Milt Sunde, G, round 20, 1964: Sunde played in 147 games, starting 106, in his 11 year Viking career, contributing to the top Viking offenses in several championship years.

6) Stu Voight, TE, round 10, 1970: Voight was a steady tight end during his 11 years and 131 games with the team, contributing during the team’s Super Bowl seasons in the mid-’70’s.

5) Dave Osborn, RB, round 13, 1965: A tough runner and reliable receiver out of the backfield, Osborn’s 4,320 rushing yards rank sixth in team history. He was named to one Pro Bowl during his 11 years with the team.

4) Matt Birk, C, round 6, 1998: Birk played in 146 games and started 123 from 1998-2008, earning six Pro Bowl nods while snapping the ball at center.

3) Steve Jordan, TE, round 7, 1982: A six time Pro Bowl selection, Jordan was a consistent and durable tight end, appearing in 176 games and starting 149 in 13 seasons. He had 498 receptions and scored 28 touchdowns.

2) Carl Lee, CB, round 7, 1983: Selected three times to the Pro Bowl, Lee played in 169 games, starting 144, during 11 seasons with the team. A key player at cornerback on the team’s great defenses in the late 1980’s, he is the all-time leader in passes defensed with 128, recovered 6 fumbles, and is sixth with 29 interceptions, two of which he returned for touchdowns.

1) Scott Studwell, MLB, round 9, 1977: Fifth in team history with 201 games played, Studwell started 161 at middle linebacker and was selected to the Pro Bowl twice. He forced 12 fumbles, recovered 16, intercepted 11 passes, had 9 QB sacks, and ranks ninth with 46 tackles-for-loss. Studwell is the best late round draft pick in Vikings history.

The worst college drafts in Minnesota Vikings history

Through the annual college draft the Minnesota Vikings selected some great players who went on to be selected to the NFL Hall of Fame (Fran Tarkenton, Carl Eller, Ron Yary, Alan Page, Chris Doleman, Randall McDaniel) as well as many other players in both the early and late rounds of the draft who made major contributions to the team’s success through the years.

However, there were many drafts where the Vikings selected mediocre players who contributed little, and led to losing seasons. Many of these drafts came under head coaches Dennis Green and Brad Childress, neither of whom was skilled in evaluating talent.

There were other drafts where Minnesota got virtually nothing from their picks. These are the worst drafts in team history, and are listed below.

10) 1990 – Running back Terry Allen had a couple of good seasons. The other players didn’t make the team or were around only for a year or two. The team’s scouts and coaches at this time had no idea what they were doing.

9) 1996 – Running back Moe Williams contributed a little bit. The remaining picks were total busts. Head coach Dennis Green was clueless.

8) 2000 – Pretty much a waste. Does anyone know what was going on in Coach Dennis Green’s mind? An executive from a rival team commented, “I think the Vikings were drunk” while conducting this draft.

7) 2001 – Another Dennis Green disaster. Running back Michael Bennett had one good year, other than that, most draftees didn’t even make the team.

6) 1963 – Wide receiver Paul Flatley had a few good seasons. None of the others made any impact, if they made the team at all.

5) 1971 – Safety Jeff Wright, taken in the 15th round, turned out to be a good player. The others were never heard from again.

4) 1966 – Running back Jim Lindsey stuck as a backup for seven years. Other than that, zero contributions from this group.

3) 2004 – Pretty much zero contributions from this draft class. Not sure what the Vikings scouts were thinking. I would imagine most are now in a different profession.

2) 2005 – Literally nothing from this group. Troy Williamson at number one was one of the team’s worst first round picks ever, along with defensive end Erasmus James. Both are examples of scouts falling in love with athletic ability and ignoring whether or not the guy can play football.

1) 1989 – What a disaster. Not one player was with the team for longer than a year. Then Vikings executive Mike Lynn was a total moron when it came to football.

The best college drafts in Minnesota Vikings history

The Minnesota Vikings have had more bad drafts than good ones. Looking at some of the players they’ve selected, it’s hard to believe they actually were a contending team during some seasons.

A review of the Vikings’ college drafts in past years did show some good ones, that resulted in players who made significant contributions to the team’s success.

Here are the best ten drafts:

10) 2012 – So far it looks like a good haul from this draft, with offensive tackle Matt Kalil, safety Harrison Smith and kicker Blair Walsh all becoming instant stars. Wwide receiver Jarius Wright andtight end Rhett Ellison have played well and made contributions.

9) 1976 – This one netted wide receiver Sammy White, who was a key player on offense during the late ’70’s and early ’80’s. Also nabbed was guard Wes Hamilton, who was a starter and serviceable player during the same time period.

 

8) 1977 – Quarterback Tommy Kramer and linebacker Scott Studwell played well for years. Center Dennis Swilley and safety Tommy Hannon also contributed during the late ’70’s and early ’80’s.

7) 1964 – Defensive end Carl Eller was selected; he became one of the best Vikings of all time and a Hall of Fame member. Guard Milt Sunde was also picked, and he was a starter during the late ’60’s and early ’70’s.

6) 1961 – Quarterback Fran Tarkenton began a Hall of Fame career; running back Tommy Mason was a good player during the team’s early years. Cornerback Ed Sharockman was a steady defender in the 1960’s and early ’70’s.

5) 1968 – Offensive tackle Ron Yary became one of the best players in franchise history and a member of the Hall of Fame. Running back Oscar Reed, cornerback Charlie West, and quarterback Bob Lee also made contributions from the late ’60’s through the mid ’70’s.

4) 1998 – Wide receiver Randy Moss and center Matt Birk were selected; both became important players and Pro Bowlers.

3) 1983 – Safety Joey Browner and cornerback Carl Lee were drafted, and both were key players and Pro Bowlers on dominant defenses in the late ’80’s.

2) 1974 – Linebacker Matt Blair became one of the best players in Vikings history, and a perennial Pro Bowler. Offensive tackle Steve Riley started and played well for ten years. Linebacker Fred McNeil was a starter and good defensive player in the late ’70’s and early ’80’s.

1) 1967 – The Vikings were smart in selecting defensive tackle Alan Page, who became a Hall of Famer and one of the best players in NFL history. Cornerback Bobby Bryant also had a great career; he was a key piece on dominant defenses of the late ’60’s and early ’70’s. Wide receiver Gene Washington became a Pro Bowler. Running back Clint Jones, wide receiver Bob Grim, and tight end John Beasley also made contributions.

The worst college drafts in Minnesota Vikings history

Through the annual college draft the Minnesota Vikings selected some great players who went on to be selected to the NFL Hall of Fame (Fran Tarkenton, Carl Eller, Ron Yary, Alan Page, Chris Doleman, Randall McDaniel) as well as many other players in both the early and late rounds of the draft who made major contributions to the team’s success through the years.

However, there were many drafts where the Vikings selected mediocre players who contributed little, and led to losing seasons. Many of these drafts came under head coaches Dennis Green and Brad Childress, neither of whom was skilled in evaluating talent.

There were other drafts where Minnesota got virtually nothing from their picks. These are the worst drafts in team history, and are listed below.

 

10) 1990 – Running back Terry Allen had a couple of good seasons. The other players didn’t make the team or were around only for a year or two. The team’s scouts and coaches at this time had no idea what they were doing.

 

9) 1996 – Running back Moe Williams contributed a little bit. The remaining picks were total busts. Head coach Dennis Green was clueless.

 

8) 2000 – Pretty much a waste. Does anyone know what was going on in Coach Dennis Green’s mind? An executive from a rival team commented, “I think the Vikings were drunk” while conducting this draft.

 

7) 2001 – Another Dennis Green disaster. Running back Michael Bennett had one good year, other than that, most draftees didn’t even make the team.

 

6) 1963 – Wide receiver Paul Flatley had a few good seasons. None of the others made any impact, if they made the team at all.

 

5) 1971 – Safety Jeff Wright, taken in the 15th round, turned out to be a good player. The others were never heard from again.

 

4) 1966 – Running back Jim Lindsey stuck as a backup for seven years. Other than that, zero contributions from this group.

 

3) 2004 – Pretty much zero contributions from this draft class. Not sure what the Vikings scouts were thinking. I would imagine most are now in a different profession.

 

2) 2005 – Literally nothing from this group. Troy Williamson at number one was one of the team’s worst first round picks ever, along with defensive end Erasmus James. Both are examples of scouts falling in love with athletic ability and ignoring whether or not the guy can play football.

 

1) 1989 – What a disaster. Not one player was with the team for longer than a year. Then Vikings executive Mike Lynn was a total moron when it came to football.

Let’s hope Vikings’ Spielman doesn’t give $9 million to another fringe player this offseason

With reports the Vikings are releasing tight end John Carlson, let’s hope general manager Rick Spielman doesn’t make any similar boneheaded moves this offseason.

Carlson is a good tight end, but he certainly wasn’t worth the $5 million a year and $9 million guaranteed that Spielman offered him several years ago. That’s the kind of money that you would spend on an impact player, someone who can make a difference.

With a tight end like Kyle Rudolph on the roster the Vikings don’t really need a second outstanding player at the position. Guys like Rhett Ellison and Chase Ford ought to be good enough. Of course, it would help if Rudolph stays healthy and plays all 16 games.

The Vikings have a lot of holes in their roster, so I hope Spielman spends money wisely in the upcoming free agency period. The draft will also hopefully land some impact players that will help the team in 2014, and not take several years to develop.

Vikings’ coach Frazier, GM Spielman lousy judges of talent – Minnesota cuts bum Jefferson

Well the Vikings dumped another bum in cornerback A.J. Jefferson this afternoon. Even though they only shipped a 6th or 7th round pick to the Cardinals for him last year, you would have thought the Vikings had landed a future All-Pro after hearing head coach Leslie Frazier heap praise on Jefferson after the acquisition.

Frazier was the one who wanted to sign washed-up has-been Donovan McNabb to play quarterback two years ago, and Spielman has swung and missed on a number of draft picks in the last few years (Josh Robinson, Tyrell Johnson, Christian Ponder, Mistral Raymond, Marcus McCauley, among others) so it’s not surprising that they wasted a draft pick on a player like Jefferson. Jefferson contributed nothing during his time with the team.

Frazier might be a good coach, and Spielman might be the type of that write up a great scouting report, but when it comes time to select a talented player, neither has shown that they have much of a knack for it.

If they did the Vikings record would be a lot better than 2-8-1.

Vikings would have been better off trading Allen, Peterson

The rumors swirled for days but trade deadline came and went without the Vikings trading defensive end Jared Allen. Too bad. Although it’s unlikely anyone would have given up a first round pick for a two month player rental, it would have been great if Minnesota had landed a first rounder for Allen.

 

The Vikings have many holes, since general manager Rick Spielman and his scouting crew have swung and missed on too many draft picks and free agents in the past few years, so any additional help through the draft would have been useful for next year.

 

What would have been even better if the Vikings had been able to pull off a Herschel Walker type of trade. If I was Minnesota’s GM and another team had offered their first, second, and third round picks for 2014, 2015, and 2016, I would have taken it. It would be better for the Vikings to add more good players to their roster, instead of relying on one extraordinary player to do everything for them. Adrian Peterson may be the greatest running back in NFL history, but the Vikings are still mired at the bottom of the league with a 1-7 record.

 

The Cowboys were able to draft outstanding players because of the Vikings generosity twenty four years ago, and won two Super Bowls as a result. Too bad no one out there in NFL land is as stupid today as former Vikings GM Mike Lynn was back in 1989.

Vikings’ coaches are dumb

Being a Minnesota Viking fan can drive a person crazy. Only the Chicago Cubs can be a more difficult team to root for.

 

Sunday’s 27-23 loss to the Dallas Cowboys is just another excruciating loss for the Vikings. What is hard to understand, as usual, is the thinking of the coaches. Why defensive coordinators slack off at the end of games when they have a lead is beyond me. They allow the opposing team to march down the field and score seemingly at will. Why not just keep playing the same way the entire game. Rushing more guys and keeping pressure on Tony Romo would have made more sense than trying to cover all the Cowboys receivers, especially since the Vikings were missing safety Harrison Smith and cornerback Chris Cook to injuries.

 

Why would head coach Leslie Frazier opt to try the Cowboys offsides on a 4th down, instead of letting kicker Blair Walsh try a 54 yard field goal? The fact that Walsh pushed an extra point attempt wide does not matter. Walsh is recovered from his hamstring injury and has made field goals over 50 yards look routine. It would have made more sense to just let the offense go for it on that 4th down instead of trying to draw the Cowboys offsides.

 

Offensive coordinator Bill Musgrave continues his conservative play calling, making us wonder what he’s thinking. Tackle Phil Loadholt is 6’8″ and weighs 345 pounds, yet can’t move anyone off the line.

 

Defensive coordinator Alan Williams said last week he wasn’t “changing anything” despite the fact the Vikings’ defense is at the bottom of the league in most statistical categories and the team is sporting a 1-7 record.

 

Rick Spielman and his scouting staff have obviously swung and missed on some players – Josh Robinson, Brandon Fusco, Charlie Johnson, John Carlson, Toby Gerhart, Erin Henderson, and Mistral Raymond to name a few – haven’t amounted to much and are some reasons why the team has only won one game so far this season.

 

If Frazier and his crew don’t win some games during the second half of this season, it’s time they, along with Spielman, be shown the door in January, and Vikings fans will have to once again look to the future for some hope.

Minnesota Vikings are a lost cause

Only the Chicago Cubs can come close to the agony that the Minnesota Vikings put their fans through.

I doubt if we’ll ever know the truth behind the recent signing of quarterback Josh Freeman.

Was it ordered by owner Zygi Wilf, because Wilf was disgusted with the team’s quarterback play, namely Christian Ponder and Matt Cassel? Did Wilf instruct head coach Leslie Frazier to start Freeman, even though he wasn’t ready to play even at the minimum level required for a professional quarterback?

Did Frazier want Freeman on the team because he’s a black quarterback? Did Frazier start Freeman because he’s a black quarterback?

Did general manager Rick Spielman and the scouting staff push to sign Freeman because of his impressive physical tools? Scouts tend to get excited about athletic players – even if they have lousy on-field statistics. He’s got a cannon for an arm – so what if he only completed 40% of his passes in a season.

Freeman overthrew his receivers so many time in Monday Night’s loss to the Giants he must have thought they were all eight feet tall.

At the start of the season I was optimistic and thought the Vikings would go 11-5 and reach the playoffs, although probably not get past the first round. Now I’m not so optimistic. I’m afraid Viking fans might be looking at another 3-13 season.

Minnesota has talented players who are not playing up to their potential (see cornerbacks Josh Robinson and Chris Cook), were over-rated by the coaches and scouts (see quarterback Christian Ponder and guard Brandon Fusco), or just aren’t that good in the first place (see offensive tackle Phil Loadholt and guard Charlie Johnson).

It’s time for the coaches to scrap the Tampa-2 defense, which clearly isn’t working anymore, either due to the scheme itself or because the team doesn’t have the right players to operate it effectively.

The offense has no creativity at all. The play calling was conservative and boring even before Freeman’s start on Monday.

Maybe this team needs new ownership (again) to go along with a new GM, scouts and coaches. For now Viking fans can only dream about the day when their team will be a legitimate Super Bowl contender.

Vikings, Spielman, made dumb move in releasing Antoine Winfield

Minnesota Vikings general manager Rick Spielman has made some decent draft picks in the last couple of years (Harrison Smith, Matt Kalil) but made a huge mistake in releasing cornerback Antoine Winfield this past winter. Winfield played well in 2012 and probably had one more good year in him at age 36. Perhaps if the Vikings had approached him when the season ended about restructuring his contract for 2013, he would have been agreeable.

Instead Spielman made a classless move by calling Winfield upstairs while he was working out at the team’s facility and unceremoniously dumped him.

The Vikings could have adjusted Winfield’s contract and remained under the salary cap, and still added the players that they did.

Now the team is 0-3, and the defense ranks 28th in the NFL against the pass. Toss in an injury to cornerback Chris Cook, and Minnesota now has a problem in the secondary.

Didn’t have to be that way. Some days I just wonder how guys like Spielman get their jobs.